July 6, 2010, 10:24 AM

Social selling or simply annoying?

Katie Evans

Managing Editor, International Research

Nearly every day I get a new announcement about a service that helps e-retailers set up stores on Facebook. I’m not talking about a fan page, I’m talking about putting products, descriptions and even a shopping cart on a Facebook page. This made me wonder: Do people really want to shop on Facebook? I certainly don’t. 

When I want to shop, I go to an e-commerce site. When I want to connect with friends and family, I go to Facebook. I like it that way. Maybe it’s because I’ve always liked clear distinctions. I always keep my peas and mashed potatoes separate on my plate and I cannot a random summer day in the middle of winter.

My point: E-retailers shouldn’t be pushing products in an online arena designed for socializing.

It’s a bit like putting a big Macy’s store in the middle of a bar. I don’t want to shop when I’m having a beer with a friend—and a big storefront would just get in the way when I’m trying to grab the next round of Miller Lites.

One of my trusted analyst sources, Nikki Baird of Retail Systems Research, captured my thoughts exactly on this topic exactly recently:

“I’m not certain yet how much commerce needs to be available when people are in community mode,” she said. “If retailers aren’t careful, they could undermine the enthusiast nature of their fans by trying too hard to sell to them.  They’re already fans.”

Well said.

I want to be clear that I don’t shun social marketing. I use Facebook—a lot. (Ok, I’m slightly a closet addict). And I shop online frequently (does nearly every day count as frequent?).  Social marketing, if done with finesse, can actually be a solid vehicle for building brand loyalty. Offering coupons, discussing new products and answering questions on a social network are great ways to keep customers in the loop and encourage them to shop. But that extra step, putting products and prices and a shopping cart on a social network page and turning it into an e-commerce site, to me, is crossing the very fine line between friendly and frustrating. Shoppers are smart. They know the ultimate goal of a brand on Facebook is to sell product. If a company offers great information and advice, consumers will remember. And when they want to buy, they will go to you.

Many e-retailers today feel they need to be everywhere. And, I can see their argument: Offering products in more places creates more opportunities for a sale. However, merchants should realize they don’t need to sell everywhere just because they can. E-commerce is available everywhere. On mobile devices, netbooks and PCs—when consumers are in shopping mode, they will come. After all, it’s just a click away.

Comments | 5 Responses

  • Facebook has ENORMOUS selling potential, but mostly as a recommendation engine. Fan pages can steer online conversations, and "Like" buttons can provide enormous credibility if it's coming from an actual friend. Agreed, facebook doesn't need to become an actual ecommerce platform - just recognize the marketing value for what it is, and can be. Great article.

  • This is still a extremely new area. There are many retailers who disagree with your point of view and maybe you should check with the masses before you post a comment to determine what is trend. There is more to putting your products on social networks than getting a sale and i'm sure your next article will explain. :) Thanks!

  • There are lots of companies making big $$ on Social. Unfortunately they are technology/media companies selling social solutions. Ride the wave. In my circle of contacts I've yet to hear a success story of translating the enormous hype surrounding Social to hard revenue. Great brand-building mechanism? Absolutely! So far the rest is just hot air for CEOs and CMOs.

  • I agree with the Author, info is OK but I do Not want to shop on facebook. Having said that their is some interest in the friends or friends of friends selling their stuff. Its kinda like a yard sale on your street. You gotta check it out.

  • This is a fine line between social properties and conducting the transaction, and perhaps an example of innovation at its finest. At EPiServer, many of our customers tell us that they struggle to find the right balance between the value of the social referral and the ability to control the shopping experience. To date, the need to control the entire check out process has led to more emphasis on driving traffic from social sites to an e-retailer. A good analogy for social commerce may be the sidewalk sale in front of a brick and mortar storefront. The shopper may be attracted to the merchandise, but ultimately has to enter the store to complete a transaction. Branded social communities may be an analogy for building bigger sidewalks.

Sign In to Make a Comment

Comments are moderated by Internet Retailer and can be removed.

Not a member? Signup for free today!

Recent Posts from this Blog


Charles Nicholls / E-Commerce

E-mail remarketing: three best practices to maximize revenue

Consumers who make it to the shopping cart are interested in buying. The chief strategy ...


Kim Giroux / E-Commerce

The five most effective retail affiliate marketing tactics

For starters, find affiliates likely to attract consumers interested in your products, says Kim Giroux ...


Vanessa Rumbold / E-Commerce

What e-retailers should focus on in 2014

Mobile, for sure, says an e-commerce design expert in a Q&A. Many retailers still fall ...


Eric Best / E-Commerce

The new structure for Google’s Product Listing Ads

Google’s Shopping Campaigns, announced late last year, ultimately will let retailers more precisely target top-performing ...