Two-year-old MTailor has garnered millions in sales for its custom-made shirts, all via its app.
Online sales tax collection seems likely, but how it's implemented will make a difference.
Steps from his office on Salt Lake City's eastern fringe, Jonathan Johnson can steal away from the hustle and bustle of running Overstock.com Inc. and head for the clear air and open views of higher elevations of 12,000-foot peaks.
But of late the web-only retailer's president has been contemplating lofty numbers of a different and decidedly more stressful kind. These numbers stem from proposals to require Overstock and other web-only retailers to collect state sales tax. That would mean raising the final price to the shopper 6% to 9% depending on the state's tax rate. Just as troubling, Johnson says, it could cost e-retailers more than $1 million per state to set up and test software for collecting sales tax on orders placed by customers in dozens of states.
The view is quite different for Seattle-based Amazon.com Inc., Overstock's—and practically every other retailer's—biggest competitor. Amazon has dropped its long-standing opposition to an online sales tax and now supports proposals to require web-only retailers to collect sales tax in the 45 states plus the District of Columbia that have a sales tax on their books, regardless of whether the retailer has a physical presence in those states.
Amazon switched sides as it began establishing a physical presence in more states—in the form of dozens of distribution centers it has built so that it can quickly fulfill orders across the country (see chart on page 36). In effect, Amazon is similar to big retail chains, with little choice but to collect sales tax under existing law. Now it stands with organizations that represent retail chains, notably the National Retail Federation, in arguing for "a level playing field" in which all web purchases are subject to sales tax.
Amazon's change of heart also reflects the growing pressure from state governments whose revenue flow has not recovered from the recession and housing crisis, and who increasingly look to online sales tax as a lucrative source of new funds. The University of Tennessee, Knoxville, estimates states would take in an additional $23 billion this year if they could tax Internet and catalog sales, although other estimates are lower.
Increasingly the question is not if online sales will be taxed, but when—and most importantly, how. The details will be decisive for many retailers. Some proposals would exempt e-retailers with out-of-state sales under $1 million, meaning many thousands of web merchants would continue to operate as they do today. Other proposals from retailer advocates would provide significant compensation to e-retailers for the cost of collecting sales tax in about 10,000 state and local jurisdictions. All of this is up for grabs in the halls of Congress, with a decision possibly only months away.
Amazon isn't waiting. As it's built about 40 distribution centers across the country, it's carefully negotiated deals related to sales tax collection. It used to be that states like Indiana and Texas would exempt Amazon from having to collect sales tax in exchange for the new jobs that Amazon's warehouse brought, notes Scott Peterson, executive director of the governing board of the Streamlined Sales Tax Project, a multi-state initiative to simplify tax collection across member states. Also known as the SST, it has 24 member states so far. But after other tax-collecting retailers, including major retail chains, started lobbying states to negotiate tougher terms with Amazon, Peterson says, Indiana and other states started negotiating contracts with Amazon under which the retailer agreed to begin collecting sales tax at a future date, typically within a year or two. Amazon now collects sales tax in six states and will collect in at least seven more by 2014.
That lessens the threat to Amazon that its business will be damaged by having to collect sales tax on orders from consumers in all states with sales tax. Amazon and other web-only retailers have benefited from a 1992 U.S. Supreme Court ruling that exempted retailers from sales tax collection if they don't have physical facilities, such as stores or distribution centers, in the state of the consumer making the purchase.
The looming tax law
But many experts say that Congress is ready to enact a law that would override that decision. Although few expect Congress to pass what many voters would consider a new tax before the November election, "everyone has their eyes on the lame-duck session" that follows, says Maureen Riehl, vice president of government affairs at the Council on State Taxation, an industry group representing major retailers including Wal-Mart Stores Inc., Sears Holdings Corp. and Amazon. That session ends Jan. 3, 2013. "If not this year," Riehl adds, "we fully expect it within the next Congress."
Among several pending federal bills, the Marketplace Fairness Act, introduced in the Senate with bipartisan support from Dick Durbin (D-Ill.), Mike Enzi (R-Wyo.) and Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.), is said to have the best chance of becoming law. Many states favor it because they could collect online sales tax without joining the SST.
And, with online sales tax laws on the books in 18 states and pending in 10 more (see map), Amazon has thrown its weight behind the measure. "Amazon strongly supports enactment of the Enzi-Durbin-Alexander bill and will work with Congress, retailers and the states to get this bipartisan legislation passed," says Paul Misener, Amazon's vice president of global public policy.
One big issue is which retailers would have to collect sales tax. The Senate bill says it would only apply to retailers with out-of-state—online, phone or direct mail—sales of more than $500,000; the House is expected to support a threshold of $1 million. Amazon has proposed a threshold of $150,000. Close to a thousand or more retailers would be affected by that decision: Although the Marketplace Fairness Act doesn't estimate the number of retailers the bill would affect, the smallest retailer by web sales among the top 1000 ranked by Internet Retailer did $184,000 in total online sales last year. 990 had total web sales of $500,000 or more; and 980 had at least $1 million.