Food & Drug:
Brand and infrastructure go hand-in-hand
Internet
Retailer`s Best of the Web 2003
Albertsons
Drugstore.com
Harry and David
Omaha Steaks
Safeway
Starbucks
Retailers early on pegged food and drug purchases as likely candidates
to succeed on the web. In fact, some online grocers pre-date the web’s
rise as a consumer channel. The failure of many of the web pioneers is
no black mark against the concept; rather, it reflects flawed business
plans of companies that thought they could create a national fulfillment
infrastructure at the same time they were creating a national brand. They
put little thought into the difficulty of persuading consumers to change
their shopping habits or their brand loyalty. The infrastructure and brand
are the reason that most of the retailers in the Food and Drug category
of Internet Retailer’s Best of the Web are succeeding, especially
the supermarket chains Safeway and Albertson’s. “If anybody
is going to make online grocery work, it has to be a traditional grocer
with infrastructure already in place,” says David Kathman, retail
analyst with Morningstar Inc.
In addition, retailers are finding that the same convenience that attracts
consumers to other categories on the web is attracting them to food sites
beyond supermarkets. Omaha Steaks, for instance, expanded its web offerings
to lobster, pricey hors d’oeuvres and side dishes. “Internet
customers are more adventurous and willing to spend more money,”
says Todd Simon, senior vice president of Omaha Steaks International.
That success prompted Omaha Steaks to open a site branded differently
from Omaha Steaks—AlaZing.com. AlaZing offers ready-to-cook packages.
The site, up little more than a year, is hitting sales targets.
Just as Omaha Steaks is finding that its catalog efforts translate well
to the web and that the web increases sales, fruit and gourmet food gift
retailer Harry & David is finding that customers like the web and
the web is attracting new, younger customers. Nearly a third of its sales
take place over the web, while portal marketing deals, search arrangements
and affiliate marketing are driving new buyers to HarryandDavid.com.
Even food-related retailers that at first blush would seem not to be able
to create a strong web presence are succeeding as e-retailers. Starbucks,
for instance. The nationwide chain of coffee shops sells a compete range
of coffee-themed items at Starbucks.com. Packaged coffee for brewing at
home, mugs, sweets and coffee makers and accessories are all available
at the site. And the web allows Starbucks to extend product selection
beyond what its stores can carry. “The web has been a terrific way
to give our customers more of a story about who we are and what products
and services we offer,” says Anne Saunders, vice president of Starbucks
interactive.
In spite of the success so far in this category, most food and drug retailers
believe there is still room for growth. “We have done a good job
in migrating customers to the web, but it’s only the first wave,”
says Anne Ashbey, senior manager of Internet marketing for Harry &
David.
Albertsons
The
richness of the web
It was
almost as if Albertsons Inc. was waiting for the pure-plays to go away.
Along with Safeway, Albertsons quietly launched online grocery shopping,
not getting much publicity while Webvan Group Inc. was the darling of
investors and the press. In Albertsons’ case, the test began in Seattle
in November 1999—and sat there unobtrusively for nearly two years.
But once the thicket of competitors started to clear away, Albertsons
moved fast. A year ago, it expanded into the San Diego market; earlier
this year it moved into Southern California, then expanded into Northern
California and Oregon. Last month, it started delivering to homes in Las
Vegas. And that’s just the start of an eastward push. “Certainly further
expansion is in our plans,” says Pam Powell, group vice president of marketing
for Albertsons Inc. But she declines to provide further details.
While the ability of supermarket chains to leverage their store infrastructure
to serve the online market is well understood, Albertsons is leveraging
the unique capabilities of the web to improve the web experience. “We’re
learning how rich the web is in giving us information immediately as to
what customers are responding to,” Powell says. “You can do it in the
offline world, but it takes time. With the web, the information is at
our fingertips.”
The changes have ranged from the extensive to the specific. For instance,
Albertsons is implementing a site for the visually impaired. At the same
time, it is being clearer about quantities of products. “People were assuming
that with bananas, say, when they saw the quantity 1, it was one banana
instead of one pound,” Powell says. “So they were getting more bananas
than they wanted.”
In addition, Albertsons uses the web site to research offline initiatives.
For instance, it has asked online customers about new products and about
their awareness of certain marketing programs and has asked them to evaluate
enhancements to the loyalty program.
Albertsons fulfills orders from several superstores, then delivers the
orders either to the customer’s home or office or to another store for
pick-up. Very few customers opt for store pick-up, Powell says, but the
chain will continue to offer it as a service to a certain part of the
market.
Albertsons has another benefit over the doomed pure-plays—and that is
that it can use its existing marketing to promote the web site. “They’re
being low key about their marketing,” says David Kathman, e-commerce stock
analyst at Morningstar Inc. “A lot of their advertising for the web is
just in their stores. It’s making a sounder business than Webvan did.”
Albertsons.com
Date
November 1999
Unique Visitors
155,000
Design By
N/A
Site Search
N/A
CRM
N/A
Affiliate Management
N/A
Fulfillment
N/A
Order Management
N/A
Returns Liquidation
N/A
Web Analytics
N/A
Payment Processor
CyberSource Corp.
Content Management
N/A
E-mail Management
N/A
Back
to top
Drugstore.com
Going
up against the chains
Drugstore.com has proven it’s a survivor. With
a name that says it all and a multi-channel strategy from the get-go—Drugstore
customers can pick up prescriptions at Rite-Aid stores—Drugstore defines
what it means to survive on the web. Now it’s showing what it takes to
thrive. And that means becoming part of customers’ regular shopping routine.
“Drugstore is the clear victor among online drugstores; its main competitors
now are CVS, Walgreen’s, Eckerd’s—the big drugstore chains,” says Duif
Calvin, San Francisco-based retail analyst.
With competition like that, Drugstore is beefing up its product offerings.
Just as a consumer can buy anything in a Walgreen’s or CVS store, Drugstore
wants to become a frequent destination. So it’s adding magazines subscriptions
in a deal with SynapseConnect Inc. and new boutiques, including sexual
aids and pet supplies. It also mimics chains in sending out a weekly flier—albeit
via e-mail—and it’s starting a loyalty program. It’s also offering services
that drugstores don’t and probably wouldn’t offer: travel. On top of all
that, it’s closing in on profitability. “We’ll be profitable in 2003 and
there’s nothing more exciting than that in a company’s history,” says
Kal Raman, president and CEO.
While most of the additions to the product assortment seem logical extensions,
the travel component is decidedly odd. Yet it reflects one reason Drugstore
has been successful: It listens to customers. “We would never have thought
of it ourselves,” Raman says. “But our customers told us they liked the
affordable luxuries they could buy from us and wanted to know if we could
do the same for travel.” Drugstore will use travel aggregator WebLoyalty
to offer hotel, airline and travel package discounts. If the offerings
don’t fly, Drugstore can end the relationship with no risk, Raman says.
Similarly, Drugstore expanded into pet products by paying attention
to customers. “We noticed many customers’ passwords were based on pets’
names, so we asked about their pets,” Raman says. “Many told us that if
we sold flea medication or pet toys they would buy them.”
Drugstore stands out not only for the variety of products—including
stocking smaller brands that stores don’t carry because there is not enough
demand—but also for how it presents products and eases navigation, Calvin
says. “They do one of the best jobs of any online retailer of creating
boutiques,” she says. “They know they have thousands of products and customers
don’t have time to look at all of them.” Expect more, Raman says. “We’ll
have lots of announcement in the next six months,” he says.
Drugstore.com
Date
February 1999
Unique Visitors
1.5 million/mo.*
Sales
$16 million/mo.
Design By
in-house
Site Search
in-house
CRM
in-house
Affiliate Management
LinkShare Corp.
Fulfillment
in-house on EXE Technologies software
Order Management
in-house
Returns Liquidation
in-house on EXE Technologies software
Web Analytics
in-house on Business Objects software
Payment Processor
Global Payments Inc.
Content Management
Akamai Technologies Inc.
E-mail Management
Kana Software Inc.
*As reported by comScore Networks Inc.
Back
to top
Harry
and David
Holding
up a mirror to the catalog
Shoppers at HarryandDavid.com may have a feeling
of deja vu when they arrive at the site: The Medford, Ore.-based retailer’s
web site looks like the catalog. And that’s just fine with Harry and David,
a unit of Bear Creek Corp. “The web site is an extension of the brand,”
says Anne Ashbey, senior manager of Internet marketing. “We want the web
site to mirror the experience in the store and the catalog.”
Indeed, it does. “They don’t do any special photography or copy for
the web,” says Duif Calvin, San Francisco-based retail analyst. “It’s
the catalog online.” But that’s good. “They understand who their customers
are; they’re almost all gift-givers,” Calvin says. “And at this site,
everything is about a very straight-forward gift-giving experience.”
HarryandDavid.com is a clean, direct site that is easy to navigate and
that, by virtue of its resemblance to other channels, is comfortable for
Harry and David customers. But the company, which specializes in fruit
and gourmet foods and operates 140 stores in addition to its web site
and catalog, also uses the power of the web to improve the experience.
One of the most recent enhancements is the uploading of customers’ gift-recipient
lists. Customers who register at the site can view their previous gift
recipients—a service that Harry and David offers through the mail to catalog
customers. But if there are no changes to recipients or gifts, the customer
can finish her shopping with one click. Changes are easy, too; clicking
on a name generates a pop-up window that displays the data. Customers
make changes right there. Harry and David has applied for a patent on
the gift list technology.
Harry and David was an early adopter of the web; its transactional site
went live in 1996. Today, it generates as much as 30% of sales over the
web but Ashbey is not content with that level. “We have done a good job
in migrating customers to the web,” she says, “but it’s only the first
wave.”
The next wave will be in attracting new customers to Harry and David
via the web. Portal deals with MSN, AOL and Yahoo, search arrangements
with Overture Services Inc. and LookSmart Ltd. and affiliate marketing
relationships with 8,000 sites managed by LinkShare Corp. are driving
new, younger customers to HarryandDavid.com.
HarryandDavid.com also gets high marks for its corporate gift services,
with a shopping and ordering mechanism that simplifies the process for
corporate customers. It’s another example of re-creating the offline experience
online. “They know their customer and they’ve chosen to invest where they
get a return,” Calvin says.
HarryandDavid.com
Date
1996
Unique Visitors
1 million (peak mo.)
Design By
in-house
Site Search
in-house
CRM
none
Affiliate Management
LinkShare Corp.
Fulfillment
in-house
Order Management
in-house
Returns Liquidation
in-house
Web Analytics
NetIQ Corp.’s WebTrends
Content Management
none
E-mail Management
Digital Impact Inc.
Back
to top
Omaha
Steaks
Surf
‘n’ turf on the web
Omaha Steaks is no stranger to direct merchandising.
It’s been shipping out sirloin to catalog customers since 1952. But it’s
the web that has made it more than a meat-and-potatoes retailer.
“We found early on that online customers purchase a wider variety of
selections than catalog customers,” says Todd Simon, co-owner and senior
vice president of Omaha Steaks International Inc. “They’re more adventurous
and willing to spend more money. They’re more likely to buy lobster tails.”
Omaha Steaks got an early start on the Internet, in 1991, through a
text-based store on the CompuServe network. It did about $135,000 that
year, but it viewed the Internet as just another media placement, says
Simon. He represents the family’s fifth generation that has owned and
managed the company since its beginnings in 1917 as a supplier to restaurants
and grocers.
By 1994 Omaha Steaks had developed its own web site, and the following
year one of the first graphical stores on AOL. Then it began to learn
the true value of the web as a selling channel, Simon says.
“We started to think about what kind of merchandise we wanted to offer
online, and the advantages the web offered that we don’t have with the
catalog,” Simon says. He notes that OmahaSteaks.com follows the catalog’s
tradition of offering steaks and complementary products, such as sauces
and breads. But products are merchandised differently online, where customers
find prominent displays of pricey hors d’oeuvres and side dishes like
Stuffed Antipasto Bread and Champagne Crab Cakes.
The success of selling through OmahaSteaks.com led to the creation last
year of a sister web site, AlaZing.com, which offers ready-to-cook meal
packages. “We had seen OmahaSteaks.com customers buy a wider variety of
steaks, potatoes and desserts, so we saw a market for complete meal solutions,”
Simon says. So far, the site is hitting sales targets. Simon notes that
online sales are growing faster than other channels, accounting for 20%
of consumer sales last year. The company, which also operates 78 stores,
reported total sales last year of $302 million.
Meantime, the company has enhanced communications between online shoppers
and customer service agents, dedicated a new staff of personnel to answer
customer e-mail, and launched a customer registration process that allows
shoppers to view their order history.
To broaden its online exposure, it maintains marketing partnerships
with Amazon.com, eBay.com, Yahoo.com, MSN.com. and iVillage.com. “Our
goal is to be as visible as possible online,”
Simon says.
OmahaSteaks.com
Date
1994
Unique Visitors
324,591/mo.*
Sales
$302 million (last FY)
Design By
N/A
Site Search
N/A
CRM
in-house
Affiliate Management
LinkShare Corp.
Fulfillment
in-house
Order Management
in-house
Returns Liquidation
in-house
Web Analytics
in-house
Payment Processor
First National Bank of Omaha
Content Management
in-house
E-mail Management
in-house
*As reported by comScore Networks Inc.
Back
to top
Safeway
Bringing
home the bacon
The grocery business is known for being one of
the toughest to bring online. Fulfillment can be difficult to maneuver
as well as costly, and many shoppers simply prefer to choose their own
tomatoes.
The industry has some of the most notorious losers on the Internet.
But it also has winners, companies that approach the online market steadily
and deliberately. A good example is Safeway Inc. The Pleasanton, Calif.-based
grocery chain is reporting online success up and down the Pacific Coast
and plans to move into markets including Chicago and Baltimore.
Since this time last year, Safeway has launched online grocery sites
for several West Coast metropolitan areas, including Vancouver, Wash.,
Portland, Ore., San Francisco and Sacramento, Calif. After rolling out
in those areas with growing success, it launched in September in San Diego,
operating under its Vons.com southern California brand. Covering more
than 730 ZIP Codes and 320 West Coast cities, Safeway’s Safeway.com and
Vons.com sites average about 100,000 unique visitors per month.
“We realize that the Internet provides several advantages that a brick-and-mortar
store cannot,” says Dave Stewart, vice president of marketing for GroceryWorks,
which operates Safeway’s online business. For example, Safeway’s web sites
provide a “Real-Time My Favorites” feature that provides loyalty card
users each time they register online with their 300 most commonly purchased
items. The list includes store as well as online purchases.
Unlike failed online grocers that over-invested in warehouse infrastructure,
Safeway fulfills orders from existing stores by professional pickers who
read web orders from a wireless screen attached to their carts and networked
to corporate computers. The system tells pickers not only exactly what
customers want, such as how ripe they want their tomatoes, but also the
fastest route within the store to shop.
“They’re doing a good job of it,” says David Kathman, retail analyst
with Morningstar Inc. in Chicago. “If anybody is going to make online
grocery work, it has to be a traditional grocer with infrastructure already
in place like Safeway.”
Safeway’s online strategy has benefited from the experience of Tesco.com,
the online store of the UK’s largest grocer, Tesco PLC. Both have relationships
with GroceryWorks, which is owned 50% by Safeway and 35% by Tesco. Safeway
has added improvements, such as making it easier to add products to online
shopping carts and developing a text-only sister site for visually impaired
shoppers.
Safeway.com/Vons.com
Date
2001
Unique Visitors
100,000/mo.
Design By
N/A
Site Search
GroceryWorks
CRM
GroceryWorks
Affiliate Management
N/A
Fulfillment
GroceryWorks
Order Management
GroceryWorks
Returns Liquidation
in-house
Web Analytics
Fireclick Inc.
Payment Processor
National Processing Co. LLC
Content Management
GroceryWorks
E-mail Management
DoubleClick Inc.
Back
to top
Starbucks
Smooth
blend of stores and web
It’s not quite coffee by the cup—yet—but subscription
coffee ordered via Starbucks.com is one of the more mundane uses that
Seattle-based Starbucks Corp. is using its web site for. “The web site
has been a terrific way to give our customers more of a story about who
we are and what products and services we offer,” says Anne Saunders, vice
president of Starbucks interactive.
Starbucks is clearly using its site to support its retail network of
nearly 4,800 stores. “Starbucks has built an amazing brand around a commodity
item and that carries over to their web site,” says Arvin Jawa, manager
with Cleveland-based retail consultants LakeWest Group. “The site is not
about shopping but about creating interest and getting people into the
stores.”
That’s true—the site features a store locator and is incorporating an
ordering function so customers’ coffee can be waiting when they arrive
at their local store. It also sells Starbucks stored value cards and allows
customers to re-load value at the site. “Starbucks has figured out the
right way to use this medium,” Jawa says. “These are things that make
the purchase process smoother in the store.”
But the site also does not ignore selling. Far from it. Starbucks.com,
which hosts 1 million visitors a month, features a range of products,
from coffee to coffee mugs and things to eat with coffee. Acknowledging
the complexity of today’s coffee makers, Starbucks was one of the first
merchants to make extensive use of online video technology. Using video
technology from Vendaria Corp. that does not require plug-ins, Starbucks
presents how-to videos for high-end coffee makers.
Starbucks also is using its web site to expand product offerings beyond
what’s available in stores. For instance, due to limited space, a store
may offer a coffee maker only in white when it comes in five colors. The
other colors will be available on the web site. Similarly, it offers cups
and saucers, teapots and coffee pots, serving items, foodstuff combinations
and decorative, coffee-themed items exclusively on the web.
On top of it all, it’s easy to shop. “The navigation is smooth and elegant;
ordering is very simple,” Jawa says. “In spite of the fact that I don’t
think this is intended to be a shopping site, it’s a very good shopping
site.”
Saunders says the company is on the constant lookout for new web offerings.
“Our customers are very tech-savvy,” she says. In fact, 90% of customers—average
age of 40, well educated with above average incomes—are online at home
or in the office, nearly 50% higher than the population as a whole. “We
like to keep the site new and fresh for them,” Saunders says.
Starbucks.com
Date
1998
Unique Visitors
900,000/mo.
Design By
in-house
Site Search
Microsoft Commerce Server
CRM
none
Affiliate Management
none
Fulfillment
HighJump Software Inc.
Order Management
CommercialWare Inc.
Returns Liquidation
CommercialWare Inc.
Web Analytics
digiMine Inc.
Payment Processor
CyberSource Inc.
Content Management
in-house
E-mail Management
CheetahMail Inc.