Internet
Retailer's Best of the Web 2004
BestBuy.com
Dell.com
GoodGuys.com
Apple.com/iTunes
MusiciansFriend.com
Netflix.com
Perhaps more than in any other product category, the retail market for
computers, consumer electronics and digital music is constantly reinventing
itself—and in a way that only the Internet can deliver.
It should come as no surprise, then, that six of the retailers in the
Internet Retailer Top 50 Best of the Web for 2004 are setting new standards
in the way consumers shop for computers, entertainment systems and even
individual musical recordings and movies. If the biggest challenge still
facing online retailing is being able to offer some of the same sensory
experience shoppers get in a store, retailers in this group are making
headway in offering that experience like never before.
Best Buy Co. Inc.’s BestBuy.com, Dell Inc.’s Dell.com and Apple
Inc.’s online iTunes Store on Apple.com/iTunes are taking advantage
of the web’s forte in delivering digital products directly to shoppers
at home with downloads of musical tracks. Although a growing number of
other web sites are doing the same, the beauty of this strategy lies in
how retailers are leveraging it to build their online customer bases for
their complementary product lines.
When Apple’s iTunes began offering downloads of digital music in
spring 2003, it helped to make Apple.com a destination site for a new
crop of customers that it can also woo with computer products.
Indeed, the new opportunities in cross-selling computer and entertainment
products are pushing market leaders to renew themselves—as Dell and
Best Buy are doing. Dell, whose expertise in selling direct to customers
with services like online product configurators, has redesigned its web
site as a more consumer-friendly place to shop for digital entertainment
as well as computer products.
But just as Dell isn’t taking its leading market position in PC
sales for granted, neither is Best Buy as a leader in consumer electronics.
The recent redesign of BestBuy.com closely ties it to the promotional
strategy of Best Buy’s 550-plus stores, offering shoppers the same
promotions whether they’re shopping online or looking at a store
circular.
Service and value, of course, remain at the top of the list in successful
retailing, and that’s a mark of all the merchants in this section.
GoodGuys.com, which does most of its site development in-house, proves
that a lean operation can offer a strong selection of entertainment products,
with some 50 brands in its mix. MusiciansFriend.com has figured out how
to serve its niche of professional musicians as well as a broader base
of consumers. And Netflix, which revolutionized the rental of DVD movies,
continues to stay in the forefront of its market. And yet it looks forward
to the day it offers even better service by delivering its digital products
directly over the web.
Best
Buy
Designing a strong market edge
For
some retailers, a web presence helps to shore up a multi-channel presentation
by offering a complementary experience that encourages cross-channel shopping.
Then there’s Best Buy. When a retailer enjoys the kind of advantage
that Best Buy Co. Inc. enjoys in consumer electronics through its chain
of 550-plus stores, it’s not a bad idea to design its web site to
copy the marketing image put out by its stores.
So when BestBuy.com re-launched in summer 2003 under a complete redesign,
its home page mimicked image for image the same face that reaches millions
of consumers each week on behalf of Best Buy stores—the weekly advertising
circular. Now, whether customers read the advertising circular, walk store
aisles or browse the web site, Best Buy will deliver a consistent shopping
and branding experience. “The redesign allows us to move into a unique
multi-channel space where we can offer customers seamless shopping both
online and in-store,” says Barry Judge, vice president of consumer
and brand marketing.
But the new BestBuy.com offers more than just the same promotions found
in the circular. It also extends an image for which the stores are known—the
advice of knowledgeable salespeople who can advise shoppers on the intricacies
of the latest offerings in digital entertainment and computer products
as well as appliances and vacuum cleaners. Its home page offers a new
research center that provides answers to pre-set questions about products
highlighted for sale in an adjacent merchandising box.
Among other improvements, it also provides a more sophisticated site
search function that shows search results in a drop-down list organized
by product section; it also lets shoppers sort search results by relevance
or brand. The shopping cart suggests complementary products with direct
links to their buy pages. Shoppers can also link from the cart to add
a product to a wish list, connect to an online application for financing
and purchase a product service plan.
Best Buy had no choice but to design a web site that would offer a shopping
experience to strongly complement its in-store experience, says Dave Ricci,
analyst with investment research firm William Blair & Co. “Succeeding
in the dot-com space is a must-do for them, because many people interested
in consumer electronics are very web savvy,” he says. “Best
Buy is the leader, and they want to further develop their front edge.”
He warns, however, that it will have to keep perfecting its site to keep
up with consumers’ demands. “If they play their cards right,
they’ll be the pre-eminent player in consumer electronics,”
he says.
BestBuy.com
Date
1998
Unique Visitors (monthly)
>10,000,000
Site Design
in-house
CRM
none
Affiliate Management
Be Free/in-house
Fulfillment
Yantra/in-house
Order Management
in-house
Web Analytics
WebSideStory
Payment Processor
ClearCommerce
Content Management
Interwoven, Vignette
E-Mail Management
Unica
Site Search
Verity
Search Engine Management
Inceptor
Content Delivery Network
Akamai
Back
to top
Dell.com
Making
a leader more friendly
Sometimes a web site can ride its forte too far. Take Dell Inc., whose
philosophy and business model are built on a direct-to-customer strategy.
As the standard-setter in selling computers direct to end-users over the
Internet as well as through catalogs, it has leaped to the forefront over
the past several years as the leader in its market.
But as well as its model has worked, it wasn’t good enough to serve
a company with an expanding array of customer segments and geographic
markets, says Manish Mehta, director of global e-business. “We had
mixed success in terms of user experience. Our focus was a little imbalanced
toward technology infrastructure.”
While Dell led the way with product configurators that let shoppers build
desktops and laptops by choosing their own mix of power settings and accessories,
it offered an overall site experience that didn’t support shopping
across multiple categories ranging from consumer desktops and laptops
to industrial servers. And with its recent thrust into digital entertainment,
it figured it was time to completely redesign its site to support a multi-category
shopping experience.
“Dell’s consumer electronics strategy is well-suited to drive
incremental sales and order sizes,” says Joe Beaulieu, analyst with
investment research firm Morningstar Inc. “There hasn’t been
a compelling reason to upgrade to new PCs lately, so the move to digital
entertainment should be a way to get people to upgrade with more megahertz
and RAM.”
Dell launched a redesigned web site this fall that makes it easier for
customers to navigate among different product segments, so that a business
owner can research and purchase servers and storage systems, for example,
then click to a section for viewing personal or business desktop systems,
Mehta says. After researching how customers preferred to use its site,
it provided order status links on every page and added more merchandising
space by removing a rarely used left navigation bar in favor of a top
horizontal bar.
“We now provide greater continuity throughout the site, so it’s
easier to navigate and understand,” Mehta says. “The site redesign
puts us back in balance with customer shopping needs.”
And keeping balance is crucial for Dell’s strategy of migrating
customers toward a wider offering of consumer products, as Dell seeks
to make its PCs the center of home digital entertainment systems. The
centerpiece of its new push in entertainment is a new multi-function computer
monitor that will also serve as a television screen for displaying videos.
“This is at the heart of our strategy of turning the PC into the
digital hub of home entertainment,” founder and CEO Michael Dell
says.
Dell.com
Date
1996
Unique Visitors (monthly)
15,000,000
Sales (U.S. annual)
$2,800,000,000
Site Design
Critical Mass
CRM
in-house
Affiliate Management
LinkShare
Fulfillment
Kewill/in-house
Order Management
in-house
Web Analytics
in-house
Payment Processor
Certegy
E-Mail Management
PeopleSoft
Site Search
FAST
GoodGuys.com
Keeping
it simple--and profitable
Walt Mulvey, CEO of GoodGuys.com Inc., makes no
pretentions about GoodGuys.com being a flashy place to shop for consumer
electronics. He prefers to keep things simple — and profitable, he
says.
“Our site is not the prettiest site, but we help customers find
products in a hurry, and when customers get to one of our product pages,
we make it easy for them to find other products and accessories from the
same page,” he says. “I’m not sure what came first, keeping
things simple or profitability. By keeping things simple, we’ve been
profitable, but because our first requirement is to be profitable, we’ve
had to keep it simple.”
Simplicity doesn’t mean lack of shopping options in its niche of
electronic entertainment, however. GoodGuys.com sells more than 50 brands,
and it serves them up through a variety of ways to shop. And it offers
free shipping on everything. “They’re highly focused on entertainment
electronics, and their assortment of brands is really appealing,”
says Kelly Mooney, president of retail consulting firm Ten/Resource. “That
definitely makes them a draw for some people.”
Among GoodGuys’ fortes, she adds, are several shopping options
and customer service features not often found on other sites. One is a
clearance area that offers products at up to 40% off but with full warranties;
another is the ability to download rebate forms. It also offers extended
warranties at 20% discounts. “They offer a number of things that
serve as incentives for customers to get engaged,” Mooney says.
So how can GoodGuys.com, which is a separate entity from the Good Guys
retail chain, afford such pricing and service and still produce profits?
One way, Mulvey says, is that it doesn’t hold its own inventory in
warehouses, relying instead on drop shipments from suppliers and products
it acquires from the Good Guys retail chain. It also relies entirely on
in-house development of site applications.
“We’re lean and mean,” Mulvey says. “We’ve built
an infrastructure and developed tools that allow us to check profitability.”
For example, he adds, GoodGuys has arranged its product databases to
let it quickly change the way its site’s searchable words relate
to its product descriptions. “If we see someone searching on a word
that we haven’t linked to the product they eventually find, we’ll
link it right away,” Mulvey says.
His development team has also arranged the site so that products in
any SKU are never more than three clicks away. “Our look-to-buy ratio
is very high,” Mulvey says.
GoodGuys.com
Date
2000
Unique Visitors (monthly)
186,000*
Site Design
in-house
CRM
in-house
Affiliate Management
Be Free
Fulfillment
in-house
Order Management
in-house
Web Analytics
in-house
Payment Processor
Certegy
Content Management
in-house
E-Mail Management
in-house
Site Search
in-house
Search Engine Management
in-house
*As reported by comScore Networks Inc.
Back
to top
Apple.com/iTunes
Tuning
in to a trend to build market
Apple
Computer Inc.’s iTunes has hit the music scene like the latest rock
star, with more than 17 million digital songs downloaded from the iTunes
Music Store at Apple.com/iTunes since its April launch. ITunes was one
of the first viable demonstrations that a significant number of consumers
will pay for music online. So the market can’t blame Apple CEO Steve
Jobs for a self-congratulatory remark after a recent iTunes milestone,
which he described as “historic for the music industry, musicians
and music lovers everywhere.”
But Apple’s road toward long-term growth and profits in the fledgling
market for legitimate distribution of digital music won’t be easy,
analysts say. It already faces a slew of competitors from the likes of
Roxio Inc.’s Napster 2, RealOne Rhapsody, Buy.com’s BuyMusic.com,
eMusic and MusicMatch. Dell Inc. is marketing its own Dell Digital Jukebox
software and devices for downloading music from Dell.com.
Still, iTunes has made its mark in ways that no one else can, and Apple
stands to reap big gains from iTunes in more than just digital music sales,
says Joe Beaulieu, an analyst with investment research firm Morningstar
Inc. “ITunes is a very effective branding campaign for Apple,”
he says.
Apple offers its iTunes software for free to entice users to pay 99
cents per song. But with margins slim at that price, particularly with
the cost of running servers to support music downloads, Apple will be
looking for wider margins on sales of its $300 handheld iPods as well
as desktops that can play digital music, Beaulieu says.
But Apple has a broader coup in the works. Its successful recent launch
of a Windows PC version of iTunes gives it the advantage of serving both
Mac and PC owners. “I was concerned that someone else would get into
the digital music market for PCs ahead of them, but they managed to pull
out the first viable online music store for the PC,” Beaulieu says.
“When they came out with the PC version, they captured the look and
feel of the Mac version very well.”
Indeed, he figures the most important aspect of the digital music business
for Apple will be the new business it will bring for its broader line
of computers and peripherals. “Apple will make money on iTunes, but
not as much as it will make on hardware sales by using iTunes to get more
young people thinking about Macs,” Beaulieu says.
And now that the latest versions of Mac desktops and laptops are easily
networked with PCs, he adds, Apple should find it easier than ever to
woo iTunes PC users with offers of new Macs. m
iTunes
Date
2003
Unique Visitors (monthly)
1,380,000*
Site Design
NA
CRM
NA
Fulfillment
NA
Order Management
NA
Payment Processor
ClearCommerce
E-Mail Management
NA
Site Search
NA
*As reported by comScore Networks Inc.
Back
to top
MusiciansFriend.com
Harmonizing
with its musical clientele
Selling over the Internet to a niche customer base
is a lot different from selling to a mass audience. But few web sites
do it better than MusiciansFriend.com.
Since only one in 10 Americans even plays a musical instrument, MusiciansFriend
knows that few web shoppers are likely to even look at the musical instruments
and related accessories that it sells. Therefore, it has focused everything
in its site—from the editorial content to the product selection—squarely
on meeting the needs of those who do play.
But MusiciansFriend’s niche is still quite wide as it sells to
a range of music lovers—from young students just learning an instrument
to professionals. To meet those needs, it offers more than 36,000 products.
“The products and services are geared to all levels,” says Rob
Gallo, consultant with Retail Forward Inc. “They have a clearance
center for budget-conscious consumers just learning to play as well as
a top-quality section for serious musicians. Also, the advice columns
and editorial content cater to musicians of all ranges.”
In addition to a broad selection, MusiciansFriend lives up to its name
by providing strong editorial content that attracts musicians (read “potential
buyers”) to the site, Gallo says. “They offer a lot of good
advice, such as improving your sound or how to get copyrighted,”
he says. “They want to be viewed as a central source of products
and information for the music industry.”
Also important to attracting customers is the use of search engines.
“We can’t do mass advertising like a lot of retailers do and
make it work,” says Eric Meadows, Internet director. “Before,
we mostly advertised in trade magazines, but a lot of people don’t
read them. Now, we identify keywords with search engines and that drives
a lot of traffic to our site.” MusiciansFriend.com also has links
to 30,000 music-related affiliates.
Selling musical instruments online has its unique challenges. Many serious
and professional musicians like to try out instruments before buying.
MusiciansFriend.com relieves some of that concern with a policy that allows
returns up to 45 days. “Guitar players especially get involved with
their instruments. We need to remove all fear from purchasing instruments
online,” Meadows says.
But not all musicians are fearful of buying sight unseen. “A lot
of musicians are on the road and can’t always get to a store when
they need something,” Gallo says. “Most know exactly what they
want and are very brand conscious. Also, serious musicians in small towns
often find local stores don’t offer much of a selection and they
like the selection MusiciansFriend offers.”
MusiciansFriend.com
Date
1996
Unique Visitors (monthly)
1,303,000*
Sales (annual)
$208,000,000(est.)
Site Design
in-house
CRM
in-house
Affiliate Management
Be Free
Fulfillment
in-house
Order Management
in-house
Web Analytics
FireClick
Payment Processor
Paymentech
Content Management
in-house
E-Mail Management
DoubleClick
Site Search
in-house
Search Engine Management
in-house
*As reported by comScore Networks Inc.
Back
to top
Netflix.com
Seeing
the big picture
Netflix Inc. is a darling of Wall Street, with
a stock price that has surged 500% in the past year to the mid-50s on
top of an expanding base of customers for its online DVD rental service.
But CEO and founder Reed Hastings compares it to the early Windows computer
operating software—better than its DOS predecessor, but still far
from its potential. “A lot of Internet retailers, even the great
ones, are still learning how to use the medium, how to merchandise through
a small computer window,” he says. “But it will take us another
10 years to get as good as we want in Internet merchandising.”
Nonetheless, Netflix.com continues to make impressive strides in perfecting
the market for online rentals of DVDs. Its patented method of distributing
DVDs—under which customers pay $19.95 a month to receive an unlimited
number of DVDs—is designed to maximize service while minimizing costs.
After customers select a large group of movie titles they’d like
to view, Netflix randomly picks each month’s selections from the
DVDs that are available on the customer’s list.
In the face of competition from the likes of Wal-Mart and Blockbuster,
Netflix is trying to do even better. It has improved site navigation by
reworking HTML coding, providing for faster page downloads. “By speeding
up our site, we increased the overall satisfaction of customers,”
Hastings says. The result: In the third quarter, Netfllix reduced customer
churn to 5.2% from 7.2% a year earlier, as its customer base grew 74%
from a year ago to 1.3 million. Q3 revenue hit $72 million, up 77% year-over-year,
and net income reached $3.3 million, the third straight quarterly profit.
Part of Netflix’s success comes from real-world logistics, though,
and not just from a great web experience. An expansion to 20 distribution
centers this year has put more customers within easy overnight deliveries.
Kathryn Cullen, principal of retail consultants Kurt Salmon Associates,
says Netflix excels in offering a simple way of getting movies that appeals
to a growing number of consumers. “Families with young children love
it because parents can’t always get to the video store and they never
know when they’ll have time to watch a movie,” she says.
But Hastings plans to provide even better service. He looks forward
to the development of broadband enabling Netflix to distribute movies
through the web, saving on operating costs while raising customer service.
“We named the company Netflix and not DVD by Mail because we’ll
offer the option of downloading or mailing movies,” he says. “We
eagerly await the day the web delivers movies.”
Netflix.com
Date
1997
Unique Visitors (monthly)
6,000,000
Sales (annual)
$236,000,000
Site Design
NA
CRM
NA
Affiliate Management
LinkShare
Fulfillment
in-house
Order Management
in-house
Payment Processor
Retail Decisions
E-Mail Management
NA
Site Search
NA