November 29, 2010, 3:06 PM
Blogger

A holiday tale of mobile bar scanning woe

Bill Siwicki

Managing Editor, Mobile Commerce

Lead Photo

A flurry of mobile bar scanning apps have debuted in the last few months, some freestanding and some incorporated by retailers into their apps. The premise is fantastic: Hold your smartphone camera above a bar code, the app displays the product along with video, customer reviews and more, or displays multiple stores where the product can be found along with prices for comparison purposes. Unfortunately, in this reporter’s experience, the technology did not live up to the hype.

Last Wednesday, Nov. 24, the day before Thanksgiving, my friend Diane and I decided to have a grand shopping expedition up and down Chicago’s famous North Michigan Avenue. I drafted her to help me with a test of mobile bar code scanning. So we were two hungry shoppers armed with iPhones and three different mobile bar code scanning apps ready to experience the latest and greatest in mobile commerce.

At Ralph Lauren, I tried opening one app to no avail. I was connected at 3G, and I could open other apps, but this app just spun the icon round and round and nothing happened. Diane used another app to scan a garment and received the message “No matches found.” At Macy’s I opened up another app and scanned a shirt—the app found no matches. And that happened again at other stores. At a specialty shoe shop I scanned a pair of shoes and up popped a shirt. We were dumbfounded.

But at The Body Shop mobile bar code scanning did finally live up to its promise, and boosted online sales. I scanned a hand cream on Diane’s behalf and the app instantly displayed the cream and numerous stores where it could be purchased. The price of the cream in the store was $24.95; the price on the retailer’s e-commerce site was $20. Diane immediately said with prices like that, she’d buy gifts from The Body Shop later online. Success.

When I got home I decided to run a few more tests. I grabbed some DVDs and did some scanning using two different apps. It worked perfectly every time, displaying the product and all the stores and differing prices.

I can only conclude that these first-generation mobile bar code scanning apps have bugs that need working out. If they can’t find matches on a product, something is wrong with the database or product feeds they’re searching. And if they’re displaying the wrong product, something is wrong with their querying.

I’m going to keep on trying and watch for app software updates, which hopefully will improve performance. Time will tell. But the companies with these apps better get their acts together quick, because if consumers’ first impressions are frustrating, consumers may never use the apps again.

Comments | 2 Responses

  • Hmm..I used mine all weekend, and it went really well. I do believe the scanners only work if the retailer uses UPC or ISBN codes. I am not sure if Macy's and Ralph Lauren have internal POS codes on their labels as opposed to UPC codes?? So that could have been part of the problem. I do have an Android phone (Droid X) as opposed to an iphone, but I think the programs are the same/similar. I used the Amazon scanner, Shop Savvy and Google Shopping. Most of the items I scanned were toys, books, cds etc. Almost everytime, prices were cheaper online. Particularly if it was offered though Amazon. Toys were hit or miss, some were cheaper online, and some cheaper in store @ Toys R Us.

  • Hola, Mi nombre es angela Vi tu perfil hoy en este sitio y obtener intrested saber que usted, porque te ves muy bien en su perfil, aquí está mi dirección de correo electrónico (angela22oneil@yahoo.com) por favor envíeme un email para que yo os envío mis fotos y le dirá más sobre mi mismo,. envía un email al (angela22oneil@yahoo.com) Recuerde que la distancia, color, religión o tribu no importa, pero importa mucho amor. beso mi querido amor angela ========================= Hello, My name is angela I saw your profile today in this site and get intrested to know you, because you look very nice in your profile, here is my email address (angela22oneil@yahoo.com)please send me an email so that i will send you my photos and tell you more about my self,. mail me at(angela22oneil@yahoo.com) Remember distance,color,religion or tribe does not matter but love matters a lot. kiss my dear love angela

Sign In to Make a Comment

Comments are moderated by Internet Retailer and can be removed.

Not a member? Signup for free today!

Recent Posts from this Blog

FPO

Jason Squardo / Mobile Commerce

Five tips for achieving high mobile search rankings

Searches on mobile devices will soon exceed those on computers, Google says. Retailers that keep ...

FPO

Gregory Kennedy / Mobile Commerce

Recommendations for creating compelling mobile ads

All advertising must be compelling to work. And in the constrained environment of a mobile ...

FPO

Jim Erickson / E-Commerce

The battle for dominance of China's Internet econony

Why are two Chinese heavyweights, Alibaba and Tencent, spending millions subsidizing cab fares? The taxi-hailing ...

FPO

Ralph Dangelmaier / Mobile Commerce

The forgotten problem in mobile shopping carts: payments

Conversion rates fell on mobile devices, while increasing on desktops during the last holiday season. ...

Advertisement

Advertisement

Advertisement