For Jack Ma, executive chairman of Alibaba Group Holdings, today is an extremely busy and lucrative day because the company he founded 15 years ...
(Page 2 of 3)
Web merchants including Buy.com and CircuitCity.com offer shoppers the chance to skip shipping charges altogether by picking up goods ordered online at the local store. Others like Costco.com and Egghead.com attempt to take the sticker shock out of shipping costs by displaying the shipping cost per item as customers shop. And there’s talk of new models like consolidated deferred shipping, which would give shoppers a price break on shipping in return for their willingness to wait for delivery.
Of the 40 web stores that Internet Retailer surveyed, only Overstock.com continues to offer free standard shipping on all orders. The mentality in which e-retailers simply gave free shipping away is largely over as e-retailers face up to the fact that it’s not a sustainable model. For like death and taxes, shipping costs are a fact of life. The Postal Service, UPS, FedEx and carriers that retailers depend on to get packages to shoppers’ doors don’t need to stage promotions to attract their customers’ attention, and they don’t need to drop prices to compete. In fact, the discounts they offer the biggest shippers like Amazon amount only to 2% to 5%, analysts estimate. “To make money as a retailer, you have to pass that cost onto consumers,” says Christopher Kelley, an analyst with Forrester Research. “Somebody pays.”
One need only consider airline pricing to get a notion of how complicated a pricing strategy can get. Indeed, Internet Retailer found little standardization among merchants. But the survey does suggest that between merchants who underprice shipping and handling to bring in shoppers and those whose rates more than cover their charges from carriers, straight pass-through to shoppers on shipping charges isn’t the rule. For starters, third -party carriers like UPS and the USPS charge merchants based in part on package weight. Most sites, however, present their calculations of shipping charges to the consumer based on the value of the items purchased.
“Nothing drives me crazier,” declares Geri Spieler, research director at the Gartner Group. “Why should I pay more to ship a two-ounce scarf because it cost $150 than a 20-ounce pair of shoes that cost $75?”
Don’t make it obvious
Why, indeed? If the drivers of shipping fees charged to merchants by carriers are weight, dimension of the package, and delivery zones the package must travel through from warehouse to customer, it might seem that that the charges merchants assess customers would be similarly straightforward.
But generally speaking, these costs aren’t made transparent on the web site. Even for those trying to be more strategic in their use of reduced shipping charges to compete on price, setting adequate shipping is a challenge. “Sometimes, online retailers’ shipping and handling charges fail to cover even their cost of shipping, with materials and fulfillment costs compounding losses,” notes David Schatsky, a Jupiter analyst. Over time, the longer-established catalog industry has gotten better at setting appropriate shipping and handling fees: a Direct Marketing Association survey found that 55% of them break even on shipping and handling, as opposed to 22% of e-retailers in the Jupiter survey.
Many retailers could attempt to bring some predictability to shipping and handling costs by divorcing shipping charges from weight and presenting them instead to consumers as a portion of the value of goods purchased. This method spreads the cost among all customers and results in a shipping charge policy that can be depicted in one table rather than customized for multiple zones and preferences.
For attempting to display that many variables for shipping on a retialer’s site isn’t practical, says Harvey Software President Burt Hamilton. Harvey Software is one of a number of software providers that’s developed back-end technology that lets companies determine which carrier will provide the best deal for shipping each order, based on weight, size, travel distance and other variables. But it’s technology that’s visible only to the retailers, not generally to their customers. “It would be a nightmare to try to show all of that to the customers,” Hamilton says. “We’re hooked into all three major carriers, and the rates change constantly. We’ve got a whole business built around that. If it was a matter of a few tables, we wouldn’t be in business.”
Divorcing shipping charges strictly from weight also allows merchants to set charges so that shipping and handling becomes a profit center rather than a cost center. In fact, Jupiter estimates that as many as 44% of e-retailers do make money on shipping-one reason the Financial Accounting Standards Board last year required retailers to disclose income received from shipping and handling as sales revenue.
Don’t give up control
Hamilton, who has a number of retailers among his clients, says his company has considered experimenting with tools that would break out shipping costs more visibly at retail sites. A number of person-to-person auction sites already provide this service, either on the site or by offering a link to other sites that offer shipping calculators.
But Hamilton is moving cautiously on that front. E-retailers offering too many shipping choices to consumers could set up problems by reducing their clout with carriers. “Retailers have more clout to get better rates with more volume. If you let the customers choose, you’ve pretty much got the customer determining your rates,” Hamilton says.
So what’s an e-retailer do to? “The right approach to shipping and handling will vary dramatically, retailer by retailer,” Cassar says. “L.L. Bean would approach it very differently than would Sears. They’re both strong, established national brands, but the product characteristics vary dramatically. Then there’s Bluefly vs. Lands’ End, which sell similar products at similar price points, but vary greatly based on differences in the value proposition. There’s no one answer.”
That said, there are still some things e-retailers can do to ease the pressure and knock some costs out of the system for the consumer without losing their shirts. “Give the customer some additional options beyond delivery today, or tomorrow or next week,” Spieler says. E-retailers with a brick-and-mortar presence can follow the lead of CircuitCity.com and BestBuy.com by offering in-store pick up.